Back to the Great Hall

Preferences: English | All Season
Vincent and Catherine talking to Eric.

Question of the Day

What do you think?

Could events have gone any different if Elliot had survived?

Winterfest is over and no new entries can be accepted. Here are the entries added during Winterfest.


Stace     2/8/2014 7:38:50 AM
Events might have gone somewhat differently, but by that point- he didnt have anyone left that he could trust. Catherine was already dead. they had just murdered Cleon Manning. He would have had to go into hiding somehow- but could have possibly returned later, and since *the book* was last seen with him- he and Diana could have cooked up something for Joe that tied up the loose ends.

Rusty / RedNightBird     2/7/2014 7:34:33 PM
I believe if Elliot had lived, Catherine would have too...

T'Mara     2/6/2014 2:23:14 PM
I don't know, maybe if he had teamed up with V&D&Joe they would have found Jacob sooner and got rid of Gabriel faster. He may or may not have tried/succeeded in rebuilding his Empire. He probably would have become a Helper of sorts (in a way he always was, think Shades of Gray!) and I think he would have loved little Jacob. Maybe since Diana and Elliott had already met Vincent, the tunnel community would finally have agreed to reveal their secrets to Joe as well, so that he would not be the only one of the group of friends not knowing Catherine's family.

LKS     2/6/2014 10:39:51 AM
If he had survived and gotten to know Vincent. He would realize why Catherine loved him. He would done anything to save Jacob because he was Catherine's child.

M.     2/6/2014 9:40:14 AM
I`m believing he would have doubts but helped. Some problems with his ego. But as there is where he comes from he knows how it is without money. He could start again and being in his position gave some from the tunnel people work or a place to stay for sometime.

Cordi     2/6/2014 9:16:40 AM
Wie auch die anderen schon gesagt haben, er hätte Vincent geholfen, wäre ein guter Freund und Helfer geworden und hätte somit aufgrund seiner Position Catherines Part in der Welt oben übernehmen können. Am traurigen Ergebnis hätte es aber wohl nichts geändert. ------- As others said before, he had helped Vincent, become a friend and helper and probably had overtaken Catherines part in the world above concerning her help for the world below. The rest wouldn't have changed.

Manu     2/6/2014 8:33:30 AM
Ich denke er hätte Vincent weiter unterstützt. Und wäre vlt. so eine Art Onkel für Jacob geworden. Aber sonst hätte es keinen unterschied gemacht.

underthepark     2/6/2014 3:33:00 AM
He would have helped get Jakob back, but it would not have made much difference. Er hätte bestimmt weiter geholfen Jakob zurückzukriegen, aber es hätte nicht wirklich viel Unterschied gemacht.

Walkingmiracle     2/6/2014 12:44:15 AM
The only thing that may have changed is that Elliot would have saved Vincent and helped him get his son back and destroy Gabriel instead of Diana. I don't see much else changing. Basically, Elliot would have taken Diana's place in this story.

Back to the Great Hall